How to photograph comics and cards
The grade only knows what the pictures show. A soft, dark, or cropped photo hides a tick, a color break, or a corner. The sharper, brighter, and more complete the photos or flatbed scans, the more accurate the grade estimate. Not a cert. Just a very educated look at the copy you photographed.
Why the pictures decide the grade
Each photo is checked before a credit is spent. Too few pixels, a soft focus, a dark frame, blown-out highlights, heavy glare, a sleeve, a slab, or a front or back with an edge cut off by the frame comes back Poor, and the credit stays put. A corner or defect close-up can fill the frame. Fair still grades, with some areas limited. The best rating wants a short side of 1,500 pixels or more, a crisp focus, and light that is even: not dim, and not blown out.
Phone or a flatbed
A phone is fine if you brace your elbows, tap the book or card to lock focus, and leave the pinch-to-zoom alone. Digital zoom throws pixels away. The short side of the saved photo has to be at least 700 pixels or the check blocks it. 1,500 pixels or more on the short side is what the best rating asks for.
A flatbed is often cleaner when the item will lie still. For comics, 600 dpi is the setting to use. A book bigger than the glass needs two passes. Each pass has to show the whole edge you are covering, with an overlap in the middle, so nothing is cropped out. For cards, 600 to 1,200 dpi. At 600 dpi a standard card already clears that 1,500-pixel short side. The grader reads the pixels in the file, not the dpi number the scanner prints, so a low-dpi scan of a small card can still fail the pixel check.
Light
Use diffused daylight, or two lamps at about 45 degrees, one on each side. Skip the phone flash. Flash glare hides foil, ink, and the title, and heavy glare is a Poor photo. Keep the shadows soft. A hard shadow across a corner can look like a defect, and a dark photo fails the check.
Background
Plain, matte, and a contrast with the item. A busy table makes the edges hard to see. For a card, the background has to be plain because centering is measured from the borders. A pattern behind the card throws that measurement off.
Framing
Shoot the front and the back straight on. Keep the camera parallel to the item, not tilted up or off to one side. Fill the frame, and still leave all four edges in those two photos. A cut-off edge on the front or the back is a Poor photo. A close-up of a corner or a defect can fill the frame. That does not block the grade.
Take it out of the holder
Slide the book out of the bag and board, and the card out of the sleeve or top-loader, for the grading photos. Plastic glare and a sleeve hide the surface, and the check treats a sleeve as Poor. A slab covers the edges. A raw photo shows more. Put it back when you are done shooting.
Comics: the four views
A credit waits on four photos: front cover, back cover, spine, and centerfold. Open the book at the center staples and shoot that spread so the staples and the page color are in the frame. Extra photos help, and they do not cost another credit: corner close-ups, spine ticks, a defect you already know about, and a raking-light shot. Tip the book under the lamp so a crease or a dent catches the light.
Cards: front, back, and the surface
A card needs the front and the back, the whole card, borders visible. Centering is judged on both sides. Add corner close-ups if you have them. For surface scratches, especially on a holo, tilt the card so the light rakes across the foil. Those scratches stay hidden in a flat, head-on shot.
Focus and file size
Tap to focus. Hold still. Do not use digital zoom. A short side under 700 pixels is blocked. From 700 up to about 1,100, the detail is only Fair. 1,500 pixels or more, with a steady focus and even light, is the bar for the best rating.
Naming a stack
For a batch, name each photo with the item and the view: ITEMID_front, ITEMID_back, ITEMID_spine, ITEMID_centerfold. Cards use front and back. Cover, rear, reverse, center, and closeup count as those views. If the names do not match, the photos are grouped in filename order: four for a comic, two for a card.
Quick checklist
- Out of the bag, board, sleeve, or top-loader.
- Plain background that contrasts with the item.
- Daylight or two lamps from the side. No flash.
- Straight on, all four edges and corners in the frame.
- Comic: front, back, spine, and the centerfold at the staples.
- Card: front and back. Add a corner and a tilted light shot if you can.
- Tap to focus. No digital zoom.
- Short side at least 700 pixels. 1,500 or more if you can.
- Close-ups of the damage you can already see.